|
HOW TO AVOID ESTATE TAX:
FUNDAMENTAL ASPECTS OF ESTATE PLANNING
JOHN G. JACKSON, ESQUIRE BASKIN, JACKSON, HANSBARGER & DUFFETT 301 PARK AVENUE FALLS CHURCH, VIRGINIA 22046 (703) 534-3610
I. ESTATE PLANNING - What is it?
"Estate Planning" covers many topics including: - planning to reduce, eliminate, or defer estate and income taxes - preparation for retirement - provide for management of assets during incapacity - taking care of special family concerns - providing security for minor children - simplifying administration of the estate
II. BASIC ESTATE PLANNING TOOLS.
A. WILL. A Will is a document that directs how your individually owned assets shall be distributed after your death. It may also deal with other matters including: - appointment of guardians for minor children - contingent trust for minors - tax reduction or deferral - waive certain administration requirements - insure distribution to intended beneficiaries
B. DURABLE POWER OF ATTORNEY. A Power of Attorney is a document that authorizes another person to handle business and financial matters. In the event of incapacity or incompetence, the Power of Attorney allows some trusted individual to manage assets and pay debts without involving the judicial system (i.e. filing petition to become legal guardian). A "durable" Power of Attorney is one that continues in effect even during incapacity or incompetence.
C. LIVING WILL. Now permitted in all fifty states, a Living Will is a written declaration that in the event of a terminal illness or disease, when death is imminent, all life-prolonging procedures (such as respirators) shall be withdrawn or discontinued. (There is currently a statutory form that combines the Living Will and Health Care Power of Attorney, called an Advance Medical Directive. Either the individual documents or the combined form may be used.)
D. HEALTH CARE POWER OF ATTORNEY. This document delegates authority to some other individual to make all medical care and treatment decisions in the event the signer is unable to do so.
E. REVOCABLE TRUST. Also sometimes known as a "Living Trust" or an "inter-vivos trust". This document creates an arrangement where a Trustee administers assets for the benefit of a beneficiary. In many cases, the person creating the Trust (called a "Grantor") also acts as the Trustee. The Grantor retains full control over the trust and can alter, amend or revoke the trust at any time. The trust also acts like a Will in that it directs how the assets in the trust will be distributed after the Grantor's death. A Revocable Trust has many advantages over a Will: - assets in the trust are not subject to the probate process, which saves time and reduces expenses - the trust provides for management of the assets during incapacity or illness - the trust is a private document, not part of the public records so complete privacy is maintained - annual accountings are not required for a revocable trust - a trust is more difficult to contest then a Will - a trust can be used for the same tax planning as a Will
III. UNIFIED CREDIT.
A. GENERALLY. Under existing laws, estate and gift taxes are unified so that a single progressive rate schedule is applied to cumulative gifts and bequests. The unified credit against these transfers currently translates into an exemption equivalent of $1,500,000. This means that there is no estate or gift tax liability on lifetime gifts and testamentary transfers up to $1,500,000.
B. FUTURE INCREASES. The 2001 Tax Act increased the estate tax exemptions incrementally over ten years as follows:
Year of Death Exemption Equivalent
2002 and 2003 $ 1,000,000 2004 and 2005 $ 1,500,000 2006 and 2007 $ 2,000,000 2008 $ 2,000,000 2009 $ 3,500,000 2010 Repealed 2011 and thereafter $ 1,000,000
NOTE that because of a "sunset" provision in the new law, the so-called "repeal" of estate taxes is really only in effect for one year. Unless Congress acts, estate tax exemptions will revert to their current level in 2011. This uncertainty makes planning more difficult but DOES NOT eliminate the need for effective estate tax planning.
IV. ITEMS INCLUDED IN THE GROSS ESTATE
A. An "estate" for tax purposes includes all of a decedent's cash, stocks, bonds, securities, personal property, bank accounts, interests in real estate, partnerships, closely held corporations, receivables, and promissory notes.
B. "HIDDEN" ASSETS. In addition to the usual assets noted above, a decedent's estate also includes the value of life insurance proceeds paid to another if decedent retained any control over the policy, pension benefits or annuities if they continue to be paid to another (survivorship benefits); jointly owned personal and real property; unpaid salary and commissions due; options, warranties and royalties; property subject to decedent's power of appointment or in which the decedent retained a life estate; coin, antique and art collections; property held in the decedent's revocable trust; and gift tax paid within three years of death.
C. Many people neglect to include the value of "hidden" assets in deciding whether estate planning is necessary for tax purposes.
V. GIFT AND ESTATE TAX RATES
The Estate and Gift Tax structure is a progressive tax like the income tax. For instance, the rate is 41% on estate assets between $1,000,000 and $1,250,000. The highest tax rate is 50% for estates and gifts in excess of $2,500,000.
VI. ESTATE PLANNING TECHNIQUES
A. MARITAL DEDUCTION. Bequests and amounts passing to a surviving spouse that pass outright or in a qualifying trust will be deducted from the adjusted gross estate. For tax planning purposes, it is not always advisable to leave everything to a spouse since this stacks all assets into one estate that may be taxed if both unified credits are not used effectively. Please note that the unlimited marital deduction only applies to decedents who are citizens or residents of the United States whose spouses are U.S. citizens. For non-U.S.-citizen spouses, it is possible to take advantage of the unlimited marital deduction through use of a Qualified Domestic (QDOT) Trust or by the resident spouse becoming a U.S. citizen before the estate tax return is filed.
B. There is an unlimited marital deduction for all lifetime and testamentary transfers. This means that transfers between spouses are not subject to gift or estate taxes regardless of the value transferred.
VII. $11,000.00 ANNUAL GIFT TAX EXCLUSION
A. GENERALLY. The annual gift tax exclusion is currently $11,000 per donee.
B. GIFT-SPLITTING. Gift-splitting is still permitted so that spouses can transfer up to $22,000 per donee annually, but a gift tax return will be required for gifts which are split.
C. ANNUAL GIFT TAX RETURNS. Gift tax returns and payment of gift tax is due on an annual basis before April 15 following the calendar year in which the gift is made. Also, an extension of time for filing the donor's individual income tax return will automatically extend the time for filing the gift tax return.
D. GIFT TAX EXCLUSION FOR MEDICAL OR TUITION PAYMENTS. There is an unlimited gift tax exclusion for amounts paid for an individual's medical expenses or school tuition. Payments must be made to the educational institution or health care provider directly by the donor. If the donor reimburses the donee for these expenses, the exclusion does not apply.
E. ESTATE PLANNING OPPORTUNITIES. The increased annual exclusion should make annual gifts a significant and useful tool in shifting assets free of any transfer taxes.
1. EXAMPLE. A married couple with four children could use gift-splitting to transfer $880,000 over a ten year period to their children without any transfer taxes.
VIII. COORDINATING THE UNLIMITED MARITAL DEDUCTION AND EXEMPTION LEVELS
A. PLANNING CONSIDERATIONS. Although it is possible to defer payment of estate taxes until the death of a surviving spouse by using the unlimited marital deduction, this will not usually result in the greatest estate tax savings. Overfunding the marital bequest will increase the taxes payable upon the death of the surviving spouse. If husband and wife have a combined estate of more than $1,500,000, estate "splitting" can reduce or eliminate taxes.
1. EXAMPLE. Husband has an estate worth $3,000,000 and Wife has no separate property. If Husband left everything to Wife, his estate tax would be zero but the federal and Virginia estate taxes on Wife's estate would be $1,016,000. However, if Husband left only $1,500,000 to Wife and put the balance in a bypass trust or left it outright to other beneficiaries, Husband's estate tax would still be zero and Wife's estate tax would also be zero. This assumes Husband dies first and Wife dies before the exemption increases. If Wife died first in this example, no marital deduction would be available to Husband and he would incur an estate tax of $1,016,000. Husband should consider making lifetime gifts to Wife to equalize their estates so that each estate would use the available credit regardless of the sequence of their deaths.
B. THE "CREDIT TRUST" APPROACH. One of the most important techniques to use in balancing equalization and deferral of estate taxes, is the "credit trust," "bypass trust", "minimax" or "reduce to zero" clauses. These formula clauses define the marital share essentially as so much of the estate as is necessary to reduce the taxable estate to the exemption equivalent level. The balance is placed in a "family trust" or left to other beneficiaries. Using these clauses can shelter at least $1,500,000 from inclusion in the surviving spouse's estate.
IX. JOINTLY-OWNED PROPERTY
A. GENERALLY. Currently, one-half of the value of property held jointly by decedent and his spouse with the right of survivorship will be included in the estate of the decedent spouse regardless of who furnished the consideration.
B. Significant effects:
1. Only one-half of the value of the property receives a "stepped-up" basis in the hands of the surviving spouse for income tax purposes.
2. Certain favorable estate elections depend on percentage tests which relate to the size of the gross estate, i.e. redemption of stock to pay death taxes under Section 303, special use valuation under Section 2032, deferred payment of estate tax under Section 6166.
D. The "Consideration Furnished" test applies for all property owned jointly with the right of survivorship between any two people who are not married. Therefore, it is necessary to trace the relative contributions made by joint owners who are unmarried. There is a presumption that the whole value will be included in the decedent's estate unless and to the extent that the co-owner can prove that he or she furnished consideration for the property.
X. THE TAX FREE STEP-UP IN BASIS
A. GENERALLY. Assets that are included in decedent's estate have a basis in the hands of a beneficiary equal to the fair market value on the date of death, hence unrealized appreciation is not taxed.
1. EXAMPLE. Dad buys 100 shares of IBM stock at $10 per share in 1970. On the date of Dad's death, the stock has a fair market value of $100 per share. The shares are included in Dad's gross estate at $100 per share and the beneficiary of the shares under Dad's will has a basis of $100 per share. If Dad had sold the stock, he would have realized a long term capital gain of $90/share.
2. NOTE. The 2001 Tax Act will modify the ?stepped-up? basis rules so that not all assets will receive a full basis increase to their value on the date of death. Starting in 2010, up to a total of $1.3 million in basis step-up may be allocated to aggregate transfers to any beneficiaries. An additional $3 million of basis step-up may be allocated to transfers to a surviving spouse. For all other assets transferred at death, the value of a decedent?s assets will be based on the lesser of the adjusted basis of the decedent or the fair market value on the date of death.
XI. CHARITABLE GIFTS.
A. GENERAL. Any consideration of charitable gifts should be prompted by a philanthropic desire to benefit charity, not by the tax benefits that will accrue as a result. Tax benefits accorded charitable gifts cannot make the donor whole for the relinquishment of his property. They can only reduce the net cost of the gift.
In an estate planning context, the threshold question concerning charitable gifts is often whether to make the gifts during life or defer the gift until the donor's death. Lifetime charitable gifts often present the more attractive option from a tax planning perspective, principally because the donor may realize some immediate income tax savings as a result of the gift, and having donated the property during lifetime, it will not be included in his taxable estate. If, on the other hand, the donor retains the property until death and then bequeaths it to charity, his estate will benefit from the estate tax charitable deduction. However, that will just put the estate in the same position it would have been in had the property been given to charity during the donor's lifetime. No income tax saving would, however, have been obtained.
As with non-charitable gifts, the simplest method is an outright gift or bequest. Unlike the income tax limitations, there are no estate tax or gift tax limitations on the size of the charitable deduction that can be claimed. One hundred percent of the value of the gift can be deducted and as much as one hundred percent of the estate.
B. SPLIT-INTEREST GIFTS. The virtue of outright gifts is simplicity. The disadvantage is that the donor has forever and completely parted with any benefit from the property for himself or other members of his family. Often, therefore, the donor will want to structure the gift so that non-charitable beneficiaries also will derive some benefit from the donated property.
There are several methods of making gifts which are partially for the benefit of non-charitable beneficiaries and partially for the benefit of charity. There are very technical and unyielding rules that must be complied with in order to get any tax deduction for these split interest charitable gifts. They should be planned and drafted with great care by competent legal counsel.
1. CHARITABLE LEAD TRUSTS. As the name implies, these are charitable split interest trusts where the charitable portion "leads" or comes first. A gift tax deduction is allowable for an interest passing to charity if "such interest is in the form of a guaranteed annuity or is a fixed percentage distributed yearly of the fair market value of the property." A similar rule applies in the case of an estate tax charitable deduction. Thus, property might be transferred to a trust with the direction that "X" dollars per year be paid to charity for "Y" years and at the conclusion of that term the principal paid out to family members.
2. CHARITABLE REMAINDER TRUST. The reverse of a charitable lead trust is a charitable remainder trust. Here, the lead interest is for a non-charitable beneficiary and the remainder interest is for charity. A deduction is available for estate and gift tax purposes for the present value of the remainder interest.
Two types of charitable remainder trusts are sanctioned by the Code - a charitable remainder annuity trust and a charitable remainder unitrust. An annuity trust is one where the income interest is fixed as a sum certain which is not less than 5% per annum of the initial net fair market value of the trust corpus. A unitrust is one where the income interest is fixed as a per annum percentage (not less than 5%) of the net fair market value of the trust, valued annually.
3. POOLED INCOME FUND. Yet another vehicle for deductible split interest gifts is a pooled income fund. These are funds set up by charities to facilitate split interest gifts from donors. It spares the donor the necessity of drafting a complex separate charitable remainder trust; he simply contributes to the pooled fund and designates the person or persons who are to receive the income from his proportionate part of the fund.
C. VALUE OF GIFT. A gift of property to a qualified organization is a charitable contribution to the extent of the property's fair market value at the time of the gift. This is generally the case, even if the contribution is of appreciated property (property whose fair market value exceeds its basis to the donor).
XII. MARRIED COUPLE WITH COMBINED ASSETS EXCEEDING $1,500,000
A. As the preceding examples indicate, if you and your spouse have an estate exceeding $1,500,000, you should consider establishing "bypass trusts" so that each of you effectively use your $1,500,000 exemptions. The surviving spouse will be the beneficiary of the bypass trust during his or her remaining lifetime. See Case Study #1 and #2 at the end of this memo.
B. The crucial point in this arrangement is that the bypass trust will not be included in the surviving spouse's estate. This can result in an estate tax savings of $1,016,000.
C. Note also that signing documents which create bypass trusts will not accomplish anything if all assets remain jointly owned with the right of survivorship. We must break up joint ownership and retitle assets into the name of each spouse individually.
XIII. MARRIED COUPLE WITH COMBINED ESTATE LESS THAN $1,500,000
A. If your estate does not exceed $1,500,000 and you do not expect it to exceed $1,500,000 at the time of death of the surviving spouse, you do not need to worry about estate taxes because the survivor's exemption will protect the estate from all estate tax.
XIV. SINGLE INDIVIDUAL WHOSE ESTATE EXCEEDS $1,500,000
A. If you are single and your estate exceeds $1,500,000 you have estate tax exposure if you die before 2004. You might consider making gifts to reduce your estate. Every person has an annual gift tax exclusion of $11,000 per donee so that you may give $11,000 annually to each prospective beneficiary, to reduce your estate on a tax free basis.
B. You should also consider some of the other techniques described below.
XV. SINGLE INDIVIDUAL WHOSE ESTATE DOES NOT EXCEED $1,500,000
A. If you are single and you do not expect your estate to ever exceed $1,500,000, you do not need to worry about estate taxes.
XVI. OTHER TECHNIQUES FOR MINIMIZING ESTATE TAXES
A. GIFTS. Every person is entitled to give up to $11,000 per person, per calendar year, without having to file a gift tax return. Married individuals may combine this amount through "gift splitting" to make gifts of $22,000 per donee.
B. IRREVOCABLE LIFE INSURANCE TRUST. It is possible to create a special trust designed to be the owner and beneficiary of a life insurance policy. In the right circumstances, this presents an ideal estate planning vehicle because all of the life insurance proceeds will be excluded from the estate of both spouses even though the surviving spouse and other family members receive the income and principal from the trust, if needed.
C. "CRUMMEY" IRREVOCABLE TRUST. For situations where wealthy clients wish to make gifts to reduce their estates, but the beneficiaries are minors, or may lack sufficient maturity to handle the gifts, gifts can be made to a trust and still qualify for the $11,000 annual exclusion. The beneficiary must be given a limited right of withdrawal for at least thirty days. If not exercised, the gift continues to be held in trust until a specified age is reached, perhaps thirty or even older.
D. CHARITABLE REMAINDER TRUST. For those clients with charitable inclinations, it is possible to "eat your cake and have it too". A gift can be made to a Charitable Remainder Trust to secure an immediate income tax deduction even though you retain the right to receive the income stream from the gift as long as you live.
1. EXAMPLE. John and Carol donate $100,000 of their stock which has a basis of $5,000 for income tax purposes to a Charitable Remainder Trust ("CRT"). The trust specifies that John and Carol will receive seven percent (7%) of the trust's value each year as long as either one of them lives. When the survivor dies, the trust ends and the remaining assets are distributed to the Charity selected by John and Carol. In this situation John and Carol receive an income tax deduction for the remainder value of the interest that passes to charity; when the trustee sells the stock, John and Carol realize no gain for income tax purposes so that the full $100,000 can be invested to produce income; each year thereafter, the Trustee distributes $7,000 annually to John and Carol or the survivor; if the trust earns at least seven percent (7%) each year, upon the death of John and Carol, the charitable beneficiary receives at least $100,000.
E. FAMILY PARTNERSHIP. Some clients may wish to make gifts to their children to reduce their estate on a tax free basis but own assets that are not easily transferred to children or other beneficiaries. For instance, a parcel of real estate may have substantial value but it is awkward to transfer a fractional interest in the real estate each year to various family members. It may be possible to create a partnership, contribute the real estate to the partnership, and then make gifts of partnership interests to family members, so as to take advantage of the $11,000 annual exclusions. In addition, you may claim a substantial discount for the gifts since the value of the interest transferred is substantially less than the face value. For instance, a gift of a one third partnership interest in a partnership which owns real property worth $600,000 may, for gift tax purposes, count as a gift of only $125,000, not $200,000 (ie. "discounting" the apparent value of the gift by 35%). The fair market value of a minority, fractional interest may be discounted substantially. There is substantial case law support for this view because of the minority partner's lack of control and minority interest.
F. OTHER METHODS. There are a variety of other estate planning techniques which may be useful, but each family situation is unique and must be considered independently so it is impossible to give suggestions which will be useful in all situations. |